Since so many friends questioned what the Sorting Hat said, I took the test again. This time --
Then I took another test, and another - and the results seesawed between the two.
The tiebreaker: when I took the character compatibility test, I was Luna Lovegood:
You scored as Luna Lovegood. You're an extreme introvert and because of this, are also a deep thinker. You ponder things others would never dream of pondering and stand with your beliefs without backing down. You find it more valuable to daydream than to socialize, because there's so much more going on in your head than others'. Most people don't understand it, but you seem to prefer it that way.
So there it is.
I am Ravenclaw. My Golden Compass daemon is a raven. I am compatible with Luna Lovegood. I worship the moon.
(And I like the Ravenclaw colors better.)
(Am I taking this WAY too seriously? And isn't that a Lovegoodian trait?)